Death, debt and a prisoner’s reckoning
Posthumus, imprisoned and believing that his wife, Imogen, has been killed on his orders, welcomes death as his release.
POSTHUMUS
Most welcome, bondage, for thou art a way,
I think, to liberty. Yet am I better
Than one that’s sick o’ th’ gout, since he had rather
Groan so in perpetuity than be cured
By th’ sure physician, Death, who is the key
T’ unbar these locks.
— Cymbeline, 5.4.12
Neville, a prisoner in the Tower, also wrote of death as relief. In his letter to Cecil endorsed 4 August 1601, he said that unless Queen Elizabeth’s indignation eased, he would “account my life but a burden unto me, and hope to be eased of it ere it be long.”3 The extracts from Neville set beside the prayer below all come from this letter, though they are arranged here to follow Posthumus’s speech.
Posthumus turns from his chains to his conscience:
POSTHUMUS
My conscience, thou art fettered
More than my shanks and wrists. You good gods,
give me
The penitent instrument to pick that bolt,
Then free forever. Is ’t enough I am sorry?
— Cymbeline, 5.4.1
In the same letter to Cecil, Neville expresses his own contrition:
[…] I do so much condemn myself for the error and offence I have committed, and so truly grieve that I have incurred the indignation of so gracious a sovereign […].3
Posthumus next appeals to the gods’ mercy:
POSTHUMUS
So children temporal fathers do appease;
Gods are more full of mercy. Must I repent,
I cannot do it better than in gyves [fetters],
Desired more than constrained. To satisfy,
If of my freedom ’tis the main part, take
No stricter render [payment] of me than my all.
— Cymbeline, 5.4.1
Posthumus’s “To satisfy” introduces the language of payment. Neville’s appeal likewise joins payment to mercy. Earlier in the letter he had offered his lands “for the satisfaction of the fine imposed upon me,” asking the Queen to “satisfy herself out of the yearly profits thereof” while allowing sustenance for his family. Neville trusted that she would accept all he could offer:
This is all that I can offer. And this I trust her majesty, in the riches of that mercy which she hath extended towards all other, will be pleased to accept […].3
Posthumus develops the language of debt and payment:
POSTHUMUS
I know you are more clement [merciful] than vile men,
Who of their broken debtors take a third,
A sixth, a tenth, letting them thrive again
On their abatement. That’s not my desire.
— Cymbeline, 5.4.1
Posthumus describes creditors accepting reduced payments from ruined debtors, but refuses a reduction for himself.45 He offers his life for Imogen’s:
POSTHUMUS
For Imogen’s dear life take mine; and though
’Tis not so dear, yet ’tis a life; you coined it.
’Tween man and man they weigh not every stamp;
Though light, take pieces for the figure’s sake;
You rather mine, being yours. And so, great powers,
If you will take this audit [reckoning], take this life
And cancel these cold bonds. O Imogen,
I’ll speak to thee in silence. [He lies down and sleeps.]
— Cymbeline, 5.4.1
Posthumus asks the gods to accept his life as a coin they minted, despite its deficient value, and close the account. Neville’s declaration of contrition, quoted above, continues with his willingness to lose his life:
[…] as I would willingly undergo any misery whatsoever that might light but upon myself, even to the loss of my life, to satisfy her displeasure for my offence, and to purchase her grace and favour to my children.3
Both use “to satisfy”: Posthumus offers his life in payment for Imogen’s; Neville declares himself willing to lose his to satisfy the Queen’s displeasure and win favour for his children. In Posthumus’s final request to “cancel these cold bonds,” physical chains, financial obligations and spiritual debt meet.6
A schedule of about 1599 among Neville’s Billingbear papers, headed “A note of my bonds when they growe due,” lists obligations totalling £1,709.7 In 1609 he used the word figuratively, describing himself as “tied unto you by so many bonds”—his obligations to Cecil.5
Jupiter and the four ghosts
As Posthumus sleeps, four family ghosts appeal to Jupiter. Descending on an eagle amid thunder and lightning, he promises an end to Posthumus’s suffering and leaves a tablet foretelling his good fortune.8
Galileo announced in The Starry Messenger (March 1610) that his telescope had revealed four moons circling Jupiter; Cymbeline is generally dated to about 1610, and Simon Forman’s account of seeing the play is generally assigned to 1611. John Pitcher and Scott Maisano have proposed that the new astronomy helped shape the scene.91011
The stage direction identifies the four ghosts and their movement:
[Solemn music. Enter, as in an apparition, Sicilius
Leonatus, father to Posthumus, an old man attired like
a warrior; leading in his hand an ancient matron, his
wife and mother to Posthumus, with music before
them. Then, after other music, follows the two young
Leonati, brothers to Posthumus, with wounds as they
died in the wars. They circle Posthumus round as he
lies sleeping.]
— Cymbeline, 5.4.8
They circle Posthumus before Jupiter descends. Pitcher thought “it was no accident” that the god and four attendant spirits appeared just as Galileo described Jupiter’s four moons.11
Jupiter also claims a planetary influence over Posthumus’s birth:
JUPITER […]
Our Jovial star reigned at his birth, and in
Our temple was he married. Rise, and fade.
He shall be lord of Lady Imogen,
And happier much by his affliction made.
— Cymbeline, 5.4.8
Galileo’s dedication to Cosimo II de’ Medici likewise connects Jupiter’s position at his patron’s birth with his character and good fortune, a correspondence noted by Pitcher and Maisano.11
William Lower, Neville’s kinsman
Neville’s correspondent Sir William Lower had seen the moons through Thomas Harriot’s telescope. A Cornish gentleman and cousin of Neville’s wife, Anne Killigrew, Lower married Penelope Perrot, stepdaughter of Harriot’s patron, the Earl of Northumberland.1213
Lower’s letters to Neville of 30 July and 6 November 1608 concern the Trelawny estate and a ward’s interests. In July he reported negotiations, discussed protecting the woods and proposed bringing the dispute before the master of the Court of Wards. In November he asked Neville to continue in his existing trust.14
The Commons Journal also lists “Sir Henry Nevill” immediately before “Sir Wm. Lowre” on the committee appointed on 2 April 1604 to consider Southampton’s restitution.15
On “the longest day” of 1610, Lower asked Harriot for Galileo’s book:
Send me also one of Galileus bookes if anie yet be come ouer and you can get them.16
Bryn Jones places Lower’s observation with Harriot at Syon House by December 1610. Lower’s letter to Harriot of 4 March 1611 states that he had seen the moons through Harriot’s telescope in London, though his own instrument would not show them:13
[…] when wee, I say, have often diligentlie observed Jupiter, wee could never see anie thinge; I impute it to the dullnesse of my lighte, for onlie with your greate glasse I could se them in London.17
He also welcomed Harriot’s work on their orbital periods:
That you have made so manie exellent observations of them I am most glad of, for you have gotten the starte of all in limitinge ther periods.17

Milford Haven
The Roman troops in Cymbeline land at Milford Haven, absent from Holinshed’s account of Kymbeline but twice named as a Spanish objective in Neville’s reports to Cecil. On 6 September 1599 Neville reported the Duke of Bouillon’s statement to Neville’s secretary that the Spanish fleet’s “design was to land about Bristol or Milford Haven,” though Neville doubted the report’s reliability. On 2 April 1600 he recalled another informant’s account: “I remember Elliot told me, their purpose was the last summer to have brought their galleys to Milford, so to have kept both the channel to Bristol, and to have barred the passage into Ireland.”18
Notes and sources
William Shakespeare, Cymbeline, 5.4, Folger Shakespeare Library. Source line breaks preserved except for one verse line divided between consecutive excerpts; the speech is presented complete across five passages. Bold emphasis and square-bracketed glosses are editorial. Omissions in Neville’s quotations are marked. Posthumus compares himself with a gout sufferer; he does not say he himself has gout. His captivity is as a supposed Roman prisoner, rather than arrest for debt.↩︎
Posthumus also mentions a gout sufferer; Neville himself suffered from the illness, as he told Winwood on 1 November 1604. Henry Neville to Ralph Winwood, 1 November 1604, Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, II (1725), p.35.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, undated, endorsed 4 August 1601, Hatfield House, Cecil Papers 87/61; Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Marquess of Salisbury, XI (1906), pp.320–321. Spelling modernized from the manuscript; omissions marked. Chapter 7 gives the fine negotiations and family appeals.↩︎
Patricia Parker, “Cymbeline: Arithmetic, Double-Entry Bookkeeping, Counts, and Accounts,” SEDERI 23 (2013), pp.95–119, especially p.104, note 14, article. Parker discusses the accounting imagery, not a Neville attribution. The speech’s grammar makes the debtors the beneficiaries allowed to thrive after abatement. Edward Dowden, ed., Cymbeline (1903), pp.170–171, also discusses the penitential argument and the legal sense of bonds: edition.↩︎
In a different transaction, Neville sought compensation in January 1609 for his expenditure as ambassador in France: “[…] if I might obtain any thing which would yield me but half that I spent in France, I would hold myself well satisfied […].” He calculates a fraction he would accept, whereas Posthumus describes creditors accepting reduced payments. Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, Earl of Salisbury, 14 January 1609 (1608/9), The National Archives, SP 14/43, ff.29–30. Quotations follow John O’Donnell’s transcription; the continuation has not been fully collated against the manuscript. Revised draft: RBA D/EN/F6/2/3. Mary Anne Everett Green, ed., Calendar of State Papers, Domestic, James I, 1603–1610 (1857), no.22, January 1609. Spelling modernized. Chapter 33 examines the letter’s argument about poverty and reputation. In the same appeal Neville compares himself to the diseased man at Bethesda who needed help to enter the water. The figurative bonds concern service and gratitude, rather than the obligations in the financial schedule. Robert Sidney’s later notice of Neville’s death says he “hath left a great debt behind him”; Robert Sidney to Barbara Gamage Sidney, 22 July 1615, Margaret P. Hannay, Noel J. Kinnamon and Michael G. Brennan, eds., Domestic Politics and Family Absence (Ashgate, 2005), Letter 252 (C81/259; De L’Isle and Dudley V, p.303), publisher record. Sidney’s notice gives no sum or connection with the earlier bonds.↩︎
Boccaccio, Decameron, II.9, Brown University, Decameron Web. Bernabò loses the wager and becomes poor; his life is later declared forfeit, and his wife obtains his pardon after he asks her forgiveness. The developed prison prayer is absent from that tale. This comparison does not claim absence from every proposed source for Cymbeline. Cancellation of bonds also had an established religious use in writing about redemption. Samuel Rowlands, A Terrible Battell Betweene the Two Consumers of the Whole World: Time, and Death (1606), juxtaposes a usurer’s money, bonds and bills with a rich man suffering from gout: EEBO-TCP A11139. This earlier conjunction supplies context, but not Posthumus’s penitential offering of his life. For another Shakespearean use of the cancelled bond, see Macbeth, 3.2.↩︎
Royal Berkshire Archives, D/EN/F6/1/5, unsigned bond-maturity schedule, preserved among Miscellaneous correspondence, of Sir Henry Neville, D/EN/F6/1. The first-person heading and provenance identify Neville as the probable debtor; the hand is not independently authenticated. The nine recorded sums total £1,709. February 1598 is February 1599 in modern year numbering. The schedule does not record later payment or cancellation.↩︎
William Shakespeare, Cymbeline, 5.4, Folger Shakespeare Library. All play quotations in this chapter follow this text. Bold emphasis is editorial.↩︎
Maisano, “Shakespeare’s Last Act,” pp. 402–407 and 420, notes 3 and 51; Martin Butler, ed., Cymbeline (Cambridge University Press, 2005), p. 6, quoted in Maisano’s note 3. Composition and any Christmas 1610–1611 performance are scholarly reconstructions; Forman’s account is undated, within his notes conventionally assigned to 1611; see the manuscript description and images.↩︎
For the astronomical interpretation, Scott Maisano, “Shakespeare’s Last Act: The Starry Messenger and the Galilean Book in Cymbeline,” Configurations 12.3 (2004), pp. 401–434, especially pp. 402–406 and 416–417, DOI. The article appeared on Project MUSE in 2007. Lower’s observation and Neville correspondence are documented separately below.↩︎
John Pitcher, ed., Cymbeline (Penguin, 2005), introduction, p. lxxiii, quoted and discussed in Maisano, p. 406; Peter Usher, “Jupiter and Cymbeline,” Shakespeare Newsletter 53 (2003), pp. 4–10, especially p. 8, discussed there. Pitcher’s and Usher’s positions are cited through Maisano’s published account. Maisano, pp. 416–417, including note 43 citing Pitcher’s commentary, pp. 288–289; his source is Galileo Galilei, Sidereus Nuncius or The Sidereal Messenger, trans. Albert Van Helden (University of Chicago Press, 1989), pp. 31–32. These are interpretations of Shakespeare’s imagery, not endorsements of a Neville attribution. The Folger stage direction specifies Posthumus as the centre of the circling movement. Maisano describes the spirits dancing “about the descending god” (p. 402; cf. p. 433); that is his account of the astronomical analogy, rather than the wording of the stage direction. For a dissenting assessment of the astronomical interpretation and discussion of the scene’s religious and dramatic functions, see C. R. A. Eager, Theophany on the Shakespearean Stage (PhD thesis, University of Leeds, 2020), pp. 131–132, White Rose repository. The play’s tablet is not named as Galileo’s book.↩︎
J. L. Vivian, ed., The Visitations of the County of Cornwall (Exeter, 1887), pp. 268, 299–300 and 459, Killigrew, Lower and Treffry pedigrees; public digitization. These pedigrees make Anne Killigrew and William Lower second cousins once removed, both descended from John Killigrew (d. 1536) and Jane Petit. Anne descends through their son John and his son Sir Henry; William through their daughter Elizabeth, her daughter Agnes Treffry, and Agnes’s son Thomas Lower. This is the relationship supplied by the printed pedigrees, alongside the contemporary letter’s own kinship language.↩︎
Bryn Jones, “Despite the Clouds: A History of Wales and Astronomy,” The Antiquarian Astronomer 8 (2014), pp. 66–86, especially pp. 68–69, journal issue. The December 1610/Syon House placement comes from the historical account; Lower’s March letter itself specifies London and Harriot’s telescope.↩︎
William Lower to Henry Neville, St Winnow, 30 July and 6 November 1608, Royal Berkshire Archives, D/EN/F7, public catalogue. The July letter’s address and closing both use kinship language. The file concerns the execution of Sir Jonathan Trelawny’s will and the wardship of his sons. The two letters concern estate business, not astronomy.↩︎
Journals of the House of Commons, vol. 1, 2 April 1604, second scribe, “Restitution of Southampton.” The entry records appointment to the committee, not proof of attendance at its meeting.↩︎
William Lower to Thomas Harriot, 21 June 1610, printed from the holograph in Henry Stevens, Thomas Hariot, the Mathematician, the Philosopher and the Scholar (London, 1900), pp. 116–118, quotation p. 118; public text. Stevens dates the letter 21 June; Lower’s own dateline reads “the longest day of, 1610.” The quotation has been checked against the printed page image. Anna Cetera-Włodarczyk, Jonathan Hope and Jarosław Włodarczyk, “Unsphered, Disorbed, Decentred: Shakespeare’s Astronomical Imagination,” Shakespeare 17.4 (2021), pp. 400–427, especially the section “Shakespeare, Ptolemy, Copernicus and Beyond” and notes 37–38, DOI. Their discussion of Lower cites his letter to Harriot of 21 June 1610; it is separate from the March 1611 observation letter quoted above.↩︎
William Lower to Thomas Harriot, 4 March 1611, printed from British Library, Add. MS 6789, in J. O. Halliwell, ed., A Collection of Letters Illustrative of the Progress of Science in England (London: Historical Society of Science, 1841), pp. 38–40, quotation and image p. 40. Original printed spelling retained. This is a facsimile of the printed edition, not the manuscript.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, 6 September 1599 and 2 April 1600, Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), p.100 and pp.164–165; quotations checked against printed pages, spelling and capitalization modernized. Immediately after the September report Neville writes: “But in very truth, I am verily persuaded that they know nothing, but rove at the matter altogether.” The April report recalls a proposed operation in the previous summer, not a landing that occurred. Shakespeare, Cymbeline, 3.5 and 4.2: Lucius requests passage to Milford, and troops from Gaul subsequently join him there. Holinshed, Chronicles (1587), history of England, chapter 18, Theomantius and Kymbeline, TCP A68197: the checked transcription discusses Roman tribute but does not name Milford in this account. Garrett A. Sullivan Jr., “Civilizing Wales: Cymbeline, Roads and the Landscapes of Early Modern Britain,” Early Modern Literary Studies 4.2/Special Issue 3 (1998), paragraphs 10–13, discusses both Henry Tudor’s landing in 1485 and Milford’s continuing significance as a possible point of Spanish invasion. His discussion includes Pembroke’s request to George Owen for a defensive map in November 1595. Neville’s reports provide a personal documentary connection to this already identified historical context.↩︎