Appendix L
Language shared with Neville’s letters and papers
All’s Well That Ends Well
Counterpoise and balance
In All’s Well That Ends Well, the king overcomes Bertram’s objection to Helen’s lower rank (All’s Well That Ends Well, 2.3):
KING Take her by the hand,
And tell her she is thine, to whom I promise
A counterpoise, if not to thy estate,
A balance more replete.1
Neville had used the pair in his dispatch of 12 March 1600. The Dutch States were seeking to stop trade through Calais from supplying their enemies. The Duke of Bouillon and Monsieur du Plessis supported the States against Villeroy’s opposition. Neville wrote that they:
do what they may to counterpoise the balance in their favour.2
Both apply the weighing metaphor to power or standing. The pairing was already available in English and is not a unique expression.2 The written marriage conditions are examined in Chapter 29.
“Think I know”: the King of France
Neville reports the King of France saying “think I know”; Helen uses the same words to the King of France. In his account to Cecil of their first audience, dated 15 May 1599, Neville records Henri IV claiming to know more about negotiations with Spain than his ambassador did:
Oh, said the king, I think I know more than he doth of it.3
Helen uses the same words when assuring the French king that she can cure him:
HELEN […]
But know I think and think I know most sure
My art is not past power nor you past cure.
— All’s Well That Ends Well, 2.1.4
The interest lies in this shared French royal setting, rather than any claim that the phrase itself was rare. In Neville’s report the king asserts his knowledge; in the play Helen asserts hers to the king.
Wisdom and constancy
Reporting his first audience with Henri IV, Neville told Cecil on 15 May 1599 how he had praised the king’s resolve in religious policy:
I commended his wisdom and constancy therein, as the only assured means of true peace and prosperity to his kingdom.
Lafew uses the same paired virtues in his admiring account of Helen:
[…]
With one that in her sex, her years, profession,
Wisdom, and constancy hath amazed me more
Than I dare blame my weakness. […]— All’s Well That Ends Well, 2.1, Lafew.
The same virtues carry the praise in both passages: Neville commends a king’s political judgment and persistence; Lafew finds wisdom and constancy remarkable in a young woman whose abilities have been underestimated.5
“Thitherward”: journeys to Florence and Lyons
On 25 June 1600, Henry Neville wrote to Cecil from Boulogne about Henri IV’s journey towards Lyons, as the king prepared to confront the Duke of Savoy over the disputed Marquisate of Saluzzo. Neville reported:
he determined to set forward on his journey thitherwards in post.6
In All’s Well That Ends Well, two gentlemen bring Helen news that Bertram has gone to serve the Duke of Florence:
SECOND GENTLEMAN
Madam, he’s gone to serve the Duke of Florence.
We met him thitherward, for thence we came,
And, after some dispatch in hand at court,
Thither we bend again.7
Both passages use the directional word for a journey: Henri’s towards Lyons, Bertram’s towards Florence. Among the 297 plays dated before 1616 in the corpus, All’s Well supplies the only occurrence. The word was common in other kinds of writing.6
Coriolanus: “Honour and policy”
Neville joined honour and political necessity when advising Winwood how to answer French restrictions on English trade. On 29 July 1600, he wrote that Elizabeth would be compelled, “both in honour and policy,” to impose similar restrictions on French goods. Volumnia joins the same considerations when urging Coriolanus to accommodate himself to political life: “Honour and policy, like unsevered friends, / I’ th’ war do grow together” (Coriolanus 3.2).8
Hamlet: Lesser merit makes generosity greater
Asking Salisbury for help on 14 January 1609, Neville described the financial losses of his French embassy and the needs of his growing family. He ended by turning his own limited claim to reward into an argument for his patron’s generosity:
And the lesse my precedent merit hath bin, the more free and the more noble will your favour be, and bind the more heereafter.
In Hamlet 2.2, Polonius promises to treat the visiting actors according to their deserts. Hamlet insists that they should be treated better:
[…] The less they deserve, the more merit is in
your bounty. […]— Hamlet, 2.2, Hamlet.9
Both reverse the usual logic of reward: the recipient’s lesser merit increases the value of the giver’s generosity. Neville adds the obligation it creates—the favour will bind him more closely to Salisbury.
Venus and Adonis and Sonnets 153–154: Help within sight, but out of reach
In Venus and Adonis, Venus longs for a kiss that Adonis withholds:
Her help she sees, but help she cannot get;
She bathes in water, yet her fire must burn.
— Venus and Adonis, 93–94.
Neville uses a related image in the same letter to Salisbury of 14 January 1609. Comparing his need for assistance with the sick man at Bethesda, he writes:
as the diseased man lay long by the pool of Bethesda without any help, for want of some to put him into the water when it was stirred, so may it be long with me, unless it please your Lordship, from whom only I desire to receive it, to do me this charitable office.
In both passages, relief is within sight but depends on another person’s help. The closing sonnets return to sickness, water and frustrated relief: Sonnet 153 desires “the help of bath” but finds “no cure”; Sonnet 154 describes “a bath and healthful remedy / For men diseased,” yet its speaker remains uncured. Neville’s sufferer cannot enter the water without assistance; the sonnets’ speaker reaches the bath but finds it ineffective.10
1 Henry IV: A royal offer
In 1 Henry IV, 5.2, Worcester returns from the king’s camp determined to hide the offer of peace from Hotspur:
WORCESTER
O no, my nephew must not know, Sir Richard,
The liberal and kind offer of the King.11
Neville uses the same formulation in his account of negotiations with Villeroy on 29 June 1599. Whatever course Elizabeth chose, he said, she would
not forget to claim and embrace those kind offers of the King’s towards her.12
Both offers pass through intermediaries, though Worcester suppresses his. EarlyPrint finds the phrase in the 1598 quarto and First Folio; its only other results are a 1683 military letter and a 1700 adaptation of the play. The correspondence is distinctive, but Neville’s later letter cannot be established as the dramatic line’s source.13
Henry V: “Peremptory answer”
In the 1600 quarto of Henry V, the French king promises, “We shall return our peremptory answer.” Neville uses the expression in two surviving letters: on 20 March 1602 he reports “a peremptory answer from my Lord Treasurer” rejecting his proposed instalments for his fine; on 8 December 1604, discussing English cloth seized at Rouen, he refers to “the King’s peremptory answer made to the Ambassador.” The latter closely matches the play’s diplomatic setting: a French king’s definitive response to English demands. Both letters postdate the quarto, so they establish Neville’s use of the expression, not its transmission from a letter into the play.14
Henry VIII: Amity between England and France
Reporting his protest over France’s failure to repay Elizabeth, Neville told Cecil that he had offered to withhold the French king’s unsatisfactory answer while the king reconsidered it. His purpose was to preserve relations between the two monarchs:
out of my love to the king, and desire of the continuance of good amity between their Majesties15
In Henry VIII, Buckingham describes the Emperor’s fear that closer relations between England and France would threaten his interests:
BUCKINGHAM […]
His fears were that the interview betwixt
England and France might through their amity
Breed him some prejudice, for from this league
Peeped harms that menaced him; […]
— Henry VIII, 1.1.16
Neville seeks to preserve amity between England and France through honourable treatment of Elizabeth; Buckingham describes the Emperor’s fear of that same relationship.
King Lear: “Without the form of justice”
Neville’s embassy correspondence records him insisting on the distinction between power and lawful procedure. Writing to Cecil on 28 July 1599, Neville described his protest to the French king over the seizure of an English ship by men of Marseilles. He had objected:
that it was done altogether without any form of justice, of their own authority, without any commission or letters of reprisal from the king, and without requiring justice first in England, as all the treaties, both old and new, do in that case require17
Cornwall acknowledges the same distinction between force and lawful procedure before Gloucester’s blinding in King Lear 3.7:
CORNWALL
Though well we may not pass upon his life
Without the form of justice, yet our power
Shall do a court’sy to our wrath, which men
May blame but not control.18
Neville invokes lawful procedure to restrain power; Cornwall names it before setting it aside. The diplomatic protest and the dramatic speech turn on the same distinction.
King Lear: “I thought it fit to send”
Forwarding correspondence to Cecil on 14 May 1600, Neville wrote, “I thought it fit to send it away by the first opportunity.” Edmund uses the same formula when explaining why he has sent Lear into custody: “Sir, I thought it fit / To send the old and miserable king / To some retention and appointed guard” (King Lear 5.3).19
Measure for Measure: “Course of justice”
“Course of justice” connects Neville’s diplomatic writing with the dispute over justice in Measure for Measure. Writing to Winwood on 23 January 1601, shortly before his own detention, Neville intended to pursue English grievances against the French “in some course of justice.” In the final scene, Angelo uses those same words to describe Claudio’s supposed death:
ANGELO
My lord, her wits, I fear me, are not firm.
She hath been a suitor to me for her brother
Cut off by course of justice.ISABELLA, [standing] By course of justice!
— Measure for Measure, 5.1.
Isabella’s repetition strips the formula of its reassuring sound. What Angelo describes as the regular operation of justice, she knows as the outcome of a corrupt bargain. Neville’s letters show the expression in the vocabulary of diplomacy; the play makes its adequacy a matter of life and death.20
Measure for Measure: “Hand and seal”
At a knock in the night, the Provost hopes for “some pardon or reprieve” for Claudio, but the visitor is the disguised Duke. A later knock brings Angelo’s messenger with an order pressing the execution. The friar’s assurances cannot overcome the Provost’s fear of disobeying. The Duke therefore produces a letter announcing his own return:
DUKE, [as Friar] […]
since I see you fearful, that neither my coat, integrity,
nor persuasion can with ease attempt you, I will
go further than I meant, to pluck all fears out of
you. Look you, sir, here is the hand and seal of the
Duke. [He shows the Provost a paper.] You know the
character, I doubt not, and the signet is not strange
to you.PROVOST I know them both.
— Measure for Measure, 4.2.21
The Provost recognizes both handwriting and seal. Where the habit has failed, the Duke offers documentary assurance that he will return to uphold the officer’s actions.
On 19 November 1599, Neville used the same formula for the representative who would collect his English pay and allowances. Before leaving, he had:
authorized one under my hand and seal to demand and receive my entertainment and other allowances
“Entertainment” means pay or maintenance. Neville’s hand and seal authorize a representative; the Duke’s authenticate the letter announcing his return.22
Measure for Measure: “Promise of satisfaction”
Reporting negotiations with Villeroy over French restrictions on English trade, Neville complained on 9 May 1600 that “I could draw no promise of satisfaction from him, although the King thought my request reasonable.” In Measure for Measure, the same formula becomes sexual bargaining: the Duke tells Isabella, “If for this night he entreat you to his bed, give him promise of satisfaction.”23
The Tempest: Promises not yet performed
Neville’s Advice recommends recalling any promise the king made to the last Parliament that remains unperformed:
And especially to call to mind if His Majesty promised anything to the last Parliament which is not yet performed; for upon the performance of that men will be like to ground their trust and hopes in those things which shall be offered now.
Ariel makes a similar appeal to Prospero:
ARIEL
Is there more toil? Since thou dost give me pains,
Let me remember thee what thou hast promised,
Which is not yet performed me.
— The Tempest, 1.2.
The Advice, from the parliamentary discussions of 1612–13, postdates the play’s first recorded performance in 1611. Both passages call an authority back to a promise still awaiting fulfilment. Neville makes performance the basis of trust in further offers; Ariel asks for his promised liberty. The shared wording is uncommon in the searched early printed texts, although the broader language of promises and performance is familiar.24
The Tempest: Forgiveness and the rights of others
On 26 September 1599, Neville disputed an argument that the French king’s pardon of former rebels discharged claims for an English ship taken by men of Marseilles. He insisted that the injured party mattered:
Although the king might pardon for offences done against him, yet he could not pardon those that were committed against his allies; or if he will, he must of his own make good the damages.25
Prospero likewise separates his own forgiveness from the offence against Alonso. He can expose Antonio and Sebastian as traitors, but chooses to remain silent; he forgives Antonio while requiring his dukedom back. In The Tempest, 5.1:
PROSPERO […]
I here could pluck his Highness’ frown upon you
And justify you traitors. At this time
I will tell no tales.
[…]
[To Antonio.] For you, most wicked sir, whom to
call brother
Would even infect my mouth, I do forgive
Thy rankest fault, all of them, and require
My dukedom of thee, which perforce I know
Thou must restore.
— The Tempest, 5.1
Neville’s dispute concerns maritime damages; Prospero’s concerns usurpation and attempted murder. In each, forgiving a wrong to oneself is distinct from disposing of another ruler’s claim.25
Troilus and Cressida: “Touching my particular”
In the Trojan council’s debate over returning Helen, Hector distinguishes his own fearlessness from the case for peace:
HECTOR
Though no man lesser fears the Greeks than I
As far as toucheth my particular, […]
— Troilus and Cressida, 2.2
Neville used the same construction when writing to Winwood from London on 9 September 1600:
Touching my particular, it will come shortly to a crisis, whether I shall return into France or not. If the treaty with Spain be revived, I think I shall easily avoid my French employment by that occasion.
“My particular” means one’s own position or affairs. Hector separates his personal courage from the public question of war; Neville’s next employment depends on the course of treaty negotiations. He returns to the expression at the letter’s close: “touching mine own particular.”26
The Winter’s Tale: “Charge and trouble”
Discussing repayment of money owed to Elizabeth, Neville urged payment in gold in consideration of the “charge and trouble saved of paying it in London.” Polixenes similarly links “charge and trouble” with avoiding a burden when he asks to end his visit:
POLIXENES […]
’Twere needful I denied it. My affairs
Do even drag me homeward, which to hinder
Were in your love a whip to me, my stay
To you a charge and trouble. To save both,
Farewell, our brother.
— The Winter’s Tale, 1.2
Neville discusses the expense and inconvenience of payment; Polixenes the burdens of a prolonged royal visit. The combination with “save” is uncommon in the searched early printed texts, though it also occurs outside Neville and Shakespeare.27
Sonnet 23: When writing speaks for feeling
Writing to Salisbury on 14 January 1609, Neville explained why he had put his appeal into a letter:
finding in myself, either out of the imbecility of my nature, or the abundance of my love and respect unto your Lordship, which is ever accompanied with awe and reverence, that I cannot so freely express myself unto your Lordship by speech as my occasions require, I have adventured to do it by writing28
Sonnet 23 follows the same movement from overwhelming feeling to failed speech, then to writing:
So I for fear of trust forget to say
The perfect ceremony of love’s rite,
And in mine own love’s strength seem to decay,
O’ercharged with burden of mine own love’s might.
O, let my books be then the eloquence
And dumb presagers of my speaking breast,
Who plead for love and look for recompense
More than that tongue that more hath more expressed.
— Sonnet 23.29
The correspondence is a sequence of thought: abundant feeling inhibits speech, and writing must carry what the speaker cannot say. Neville addresses a patron; the sonnet addresses a beloved.
Lucrece and 1 Henry IV: Blood washing away disgrace
From the Tower on 31 July 1602, Neville imagined military service as a way to remove the stain of his disgrace in Elizabeth’s eyes:
And if there be no other means to wipe away this blot wherewith I am soiled, yet it is possible that if I were at liberty, I might shed so much of my blood, in some place where she hath occasion to use men, as might serve for a laver for the crime which hath made me so ugly in her eye.30
Lucrece also imagines blood washing away a stain upon her name:
My blood shall wash the slander of mine ill;
My life’s foul deed my life’s fair end shall free it.31
Neville’s “laver” is a washing or cleansing: he offers to shed blood in the queen’s service to wipe away his political disgrace. Lucrece, who has been raped, imagines her death removing the slander attached to her. The circumstances differ, but both passages turn shed blood into a means of restoring a damaged name.
Prince Hal makes the military purpose explicit in 1 Henry IV. Promising his father that he will redeem his reputation by defeating Hotspur, he says:
PRINCE
I will redeem all this on Percy’s head,
And, in the closing of some glorious day,
Be bold to tell you that I am your son,
When I will wear a garment all of blood
And stain my favors in a bloody mask,
Which, washed away, shall scour my shame with it.
— 1 Henry IV, 3.2.30
Both Neville and Hal imagine military service restoring royal favour, with blood and washing removing disgrace. Neville offers his own shed blood as the cleansing medium; Hal imagines the blood upon him being washed away with his shame.
The Merchant of Venice and Hamlet: An estate disabled—land, bonds and assurances
On 6 May 1598, Neville asked Cecil to consider the danger that employment abroad would pose to his finances. He had sold land to buy part of Sir Henry Unton’s estate and faced obligations that required his attention:
I am entered into recognizances of above twelve thousand pound to be discharged within three months, and all reciprocal assurances within that time to be performed. How impossible it is for me to accomplish this if I should be employed I do assuredly know. And not accomplishing it, I foresee the overthrow of my poor estate, and shall both serve her Majesty without comfort now, and be utterly disabled to serve her in any sort hereafter.32
Bassanio uses the same pairing of estate and disability to explain his financial position:
BASSANIO
’Tis not unknown to you, Antonio,
How much I have disabled mine estate
By something showing a more swelling port
Than my faint means would grant continuance.
— The Merchant of Venice, 1.1.33
Bassanio’s expenditure has disabled his estate; Neville fears that the loss of his estate will disable his service. The same vocabulary connects financial resources with the capacity to act.
The letter’s recognizances and assurances also belong to the world of land transactions that Hamlet evokes in the graveyard:
HAMLET […] Hum, this fellow might
be in ’s time a great buyer of land, with his statutes,
his recognizances, his fines, his double vouchers,
his recoveries. […]
— Hamlet, 5.1.33
When Horatio confirms that parchment is made from sheep and calf skins, Hamlet turns legal security into a joke:
HAMLET They are sheep and calves which seek out
assurance in that. […]
— Hamlet, 5.1.33
These are connected terms from the business of buying land and securing title. Neville describes the obligations that could ruin him; Hamlet asks what such elaborate securities leave their owner at death.
3 Henry VI and Measure for Measure: Hollow friendship
Neville distrusted the durability of French friendship as Henri IV drew closer to Rome. On 14 May 1600 he wrote to Cecil:
For the friendship is very hollow, and will grow every day more unsound, as his combination with Rome groweth more strait […]
Edward IV likewise prefers open enemies to unreliable allies:
I rather wish you foes than hollow friends.
But if you mind to hold your true obedience,
Give me assurance with some friendly vow,
That I may never have you in suspect.— 3 Henry VI, 4.1, Edward IV.
Both passages distrust professed friendship in a political relationship. Neville’s further opposition between hollow and sound also appears in the Duke’s examination of penitence in Measure for Measure, 2.3.34
Several plays: “Absolute power”—a phrase found by comparison
Our independent study looked for phrases that Shakespeare uses repeatedly but other playwrights use rarely. “Absolute power” stood out: in the 239-play comparison set dated 1590–1615, it appears in four Shakespeare plays—Measure for Measure, King Lear, Timon of Athens and Coriolanus—but in only one play by another dramatist, Ben Jonson’s Sejanus His Fall. Neville uses the same phrase in his diplomatic correspondence.35
On 12 March 1600, Neville reported to Cecil on the negotiations for Henri IV’s marriage to the Princess of Florence, Marie de’ Medici. He expected the French negotiator, Sillery, to have reached Florence:
and Monsieur de Sillery is by this time I suppose at Florence, with absolute power to conclude the contract there publicly.36
The letter precedes all five play witnesses in the comparison. Three of the Shakespeare passages use the expression in closely related situations: authority is delegated, restored or offered to someone for a defined purpose.
In Measure for Measure, the Duke explains the authority he has entrusted to Angelo:
DUKE […]
I have delivered to Lord Angelo,
A man of stricture and firm abstinence,
My absolute power and place here in Vienna,
And he supposes me traveled to Poland,
For so I have strewed it in the common ear,
And so it is received. Now, pious sir,
You will demand of me why I do this.
— Measure for Measure, 1.3.37
In King Lear, Albany declares his intention to restore authority to the old king:
ALBANY […]
Shall be applied. For us, we will resign,
During the life of this old Majesty,
To him our absolute power; you to your rights,
With boot and such addition as your Honors
Have more than merited. All friends shall taste
The wages of their virtue, and all foes
The cup of their deservings. O, see, see!
— King Lear, 5.3.37
In Timon of Athens, the senators offer Timon command of the city’s defence:
FIRST SENATOR
Therefore, so please thee to return with us
And of our Athens, thine and ours, to take
The captainship, thou shalt be met with thanks;
Allowed with absolute power, and thy good name
Live with authority. So soon we shall drive back
Of Alcibiades th’ approaches wild,
Who like a boar too savage doth root up
His country’s peace.
— Timon of Athens, 5.1.37
In Coriolanus, the phrase describes the people’s political authority in Greece:
CORIOLANUS
Though there the people had more absolute power,
I say they nourished disobedience, fed
The ruin of the state.
— Coriolanus, 3.1.37
Cymbeline: “Wishes you all happiness”
Posthumus closes his letter to Imogen, “So he wishes you all happiness.” Neville used the same closing wish in two letters to Winwood: on 21 June 1605, “wishing you all happiness and contentment in your employment”; and on 13 August 1609, “wishing you all happiness in going, staying, and returning.”38
Historical and biographical parallels
Henry V: Rycote and the soldier-wooer
Henry’s courtship in Henry V has an earlier parallel in the entertainment given for Elizabeth at Lord Norreys’s Rycote in 1592. A soldier’s love letter, mistakenly read before the queen, opposes military action to literary courtship:
You say love cannot be in soldiers, I swear it is, only this the difference, that we prove it by the sword, others by their sonnets; theirs ink, black for cold, ours blood, red for heat.39
Henry likewise presents himself to Katherine as a soldier unequal to a poet’s wooing:
KING HENRY Marry, if you would put me to verses or
to dance for your sake, Kate, why you undid me.
For the one, I have neither words nor measure; and
for the other, I have no strength in measure, yet a
reasonable measure in strength. If I could win a
lady at leapfrog or by vaulting into my saddle with
my armor on my back, under the correction of
bragging be it spoken, I should quickly leap into a
wife. Or if I might buffet for my love, or bound my
horse for her favors, I could lay on like a butcher
and sit like a jackanapes, never off. …40
Both passages contrast poetry with the soldier’s way of proving his love: the Rycote letter sets sword against sonnets, while Henry offers feats of strength and horsemanship instead of verses. The Neville-family connection extends to the entertainment’s expenses: a 1917 sale catalogue records a letter from Lord Norreys to Sir Henry Neville concerning payment of thirty soldiers’ wages in connection with Elizabeth’s entertainment at Rycote in 1592. The catalogue dates the letter to 1599; if 1592 was intended, its recipient was Neville’s father.41
Rycote and Neville: Declarations sealed with blood
Another speaker at Rycote offers Elizabeth his life in the language of a document made binding:
For myself, I can but wish all happiness to her highness, and any occasion that what my tongue delivers, my blood may seal, the end of my service, that in her service my life may end.
Writing to Robert Cecil on 7 January 1603, Neville likewise makes blood the guarantee of his declaration of gratitude:
I shall ever hold, not only my poor fortune, but my life well spent to give your honour any testimony of my thankfulness. And with this protestation (which I will always avow, and seal with my blood, if occasion require it) …42
In each passage, words become an undertaking guaranteed by the speaker’s life. The 1600 report of Anthony Sherley’s Persian journey offers a useful contemporary comparison: his oration speaks of devotion and observances “sealed with my blood,” offered to be “shed and spent” at the ruler’s command. Blood as a seal thus belongs to a wider language of personal service, as well as linking these two passages.43
As You Like It: “At every sentence’ end”
The Rycote entertainment of 1592 gives its final messenger a comic excuse for arriving late: lovers have detained him on the way.
… at every mile’s end a lover, at every sentence end a lie, I stayed to hear the conclusions …
In As You Like It, Orlando’s verses make the same position in a sentence the place for his beloved’s name:
But upon the fairest boughs,
Or at every sentence’ end,
Will I “Rosalinda” write,
Teaching all that read to know
The quintessence of every sprite
Heaven would in little show.44
The shared phrase belongs to the language of lovers in both passages: Rycote makes each sentence end in a lie, while Orlando makes it end in Rosalind’s name. An earlier English Eunapius supplies a precedent for the wording, describing an orator clapping his hands “at every sentence end”; the courtship application brings Rycote and Shakespeare closer together.45
Macbeth: The king’s healing hand
In Macbeth, Edward the Confessor’s touch heals the sick. The rightful king’s body restores other bodies.
Neville had reported royal healing during his French embassy. Writing to Cecil on 13 July 1599, he noted:
Upon Sunday last the king healed a great many, both of Spaniards and others.46
The king Neville describes is Henri IV of France.
In Macbeth, Malcolm reports the English king’s cures:
MALCOLM
[…]
The mere despair of surgery, he cures,
Hanging a golden stamp about their necks,
Put on with holy prayers; and, ’tis spoken,
To the succeeding royalty he leaves
The healing benediction. […]— Macbeth, 4.3.47
The practice rested on a belief that a monarch’s touch could cure the disease called the king’s evil, commonly identified as scrofula. Holinshed explicitly credits Edward with healing and prophecy and says that he left the healing virtue as an inheritance to his successors. Shakespeare had that material in his historical source.48
Macbeth: The reasons against the deed
Neville’s declaration of 2 March 1601 explains his obligations towards Robert Cecil:
And further, seeing I perceived it was directed among other against Mr. Secretary, I said I would have no hand nor be no actor in it, because I was near allied unto him and had been beholden to him, as all the world took knowledge; and I would not blot my reputation to be false unto him or any man.49
Macbeth likewise invokes his obligations towards Duncan:
MACBETH
[…] He’s here in double trust:
First, as I am his kinsman and his subject,
Strong both against the deed; then, as his host,
Who should against his murderer shut the door,
Not bear the knife myself. […]
—Macbeth 1.750
When Lady Macbeth enters, he announces his refusal:
MACBETH
We will proceed no further in this business.
He hath honored me of late, and I have bought
Golden opinions from all sorts of people,
Which would be worn now in their newest gloss,
Not cast aside so soon.
—Macbeth 1.750
Kinship, obligation and reputation connect the passages. Neville had been “beholden” to Cecil; Duncan has recently honored Macbeth. Neville will not “blot” his reputation; Macbeth wants to preserve the good opinion he has earned. Neville presents himself as refusing participation in a retrospective defence; Macbeth withdraws his refusal under his wife’s pressure.
Several plays: Wax figures and the Windsor accusations
The Windsor witchcraft accusations of 1579 brought wax images into the official responsibilities of Neville’s father, Sir Henry Neville. The printed account attributed to Elizabeth Stile a confession involving four figures of red wax pierced with hawthorn prickles. On 16 January 1579 the Privy Council instructed the elder Neville and the Dean of Windsor to investigate allegations that people had been killed through wax images. Similar devices had recently been suspected against Elizabeth I, giving the inquiry a political urgency. These were accusations the authorities investigated, not established accounts of supernatural harm.51
Two Shakespeare passages turn the destruction of a wax figure into an image of human change. Proteus describes his fading love for Julia:
PROTEUS
[…]
That I did love, for now my love is thawed,
Which like a waxen image ’gainst a fire
Bears no impression of the thing it was.— The Two Gentlemen of Verona, 2.4.
In King John, the wounded Melun uses the same image to explain that he is dying and therefore has no reason to deceive his hearers:
MELUN
Have I not hideous death within my view,
Retaining but a quantity of life,
Which bleeds away even as a form of wax
Resolveth from his figure ’gainst the fire?— King John, 5.4.
The second comparison is especially close to the premise of image magic: the destruction of a figure corresponds to a person’s bodily decline and death. The Windsor pamphlet describes piercing figures, whereas both plays describe melting them. Neither scene stages a magical ritual; the interest is the imagery of wax figures in plays beside an investigation involving Neville’s father.52
A related image appears in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. Theseus tells Hermia that her father possesses authority over the daughter he has fashioned:
THESEUS
[…]
To whom you are but as a form in wax
By him imprinted, and within his power
To leave the figure or disfigure it.— A Midsummer Night’s Dream, 1.1.
Here the wax figure expresses parental power to preserve or destroy a form, rather than a magical attack.53
Books and classical sources
All’s Well That Ends Well: “O, that ‘had’”
The Countess interrupts herself while remembering Helen’s father (All’s Well That Ends Well, 1.1):
COUNTESS This young gentlewoman had a father—O,
that “had,” how sad a passage ’tis!—whose skill
was almost as great as his honesty; had it stretched
so far, would have made nature immortal, and
death should have play for lack of work.54
John Davies of Hereford opens his poem to Henry Neville in Microcosmos (1603) with a similar interruption, this time over “was”:
There was a Time when, ah that so there was,
Whie not there is? There is and was a Time,54
Both speakers pause over their own past tense. The Countess mourns a dead physician; Davies immediately challenges his “was” and turns to the freedom to speak and praise honestly. His Neville poem is discussed more fully in Chapter 49, “Microcosmos: Neville and Shakespeare.”54
Coriolanus: Cuffe’s leanness and superfluity
Neville’s March 1601 declaration describes repeated approaches by Henry Cuffe concerning Essex’s plans. Cuffe’s The Differences of the Ages of Mans Life, published in 1607, treats nutrition in terms of the body’s proper balance. “All mixture of superfluities,” he writes, “is against nature, enemy to good digestion, and sound nutrition.” Excessive waking, by contrast, consumes the vital juice and “causeth leanness in the body.”55
The First Citizen turns these bodily conditions into a description of unequal distribution:
FIRST CITIZEN We are accounted poor citizens, the patricians
good. What authority surfeits on would
relieve us. If they would yield us but the superfluity
while it were wholesome, we might guess they
relieved us humanely. But they think we are too
dear. The leanness that afflicts us, the object of our
misery, is as an inventory to particularize their
abundance; our sufferance is a gain to them. Let
us revenge this with our pikes ere we become
rakes; for the gods know I speak this in hunger for
bread, not in thirst for revenge.
— Coriolanus, 1.1.56
North also describes purging Rome’s “superfluous ill humours.” The sharper comparison with Cuffe is the pairing of superfluity and leanness: Cuffe treats them as disorders of the body; the citizen distributes them between rich and poor. Cuffe’s work on the ages of man is discussed more fully in the As You Like It chapter.
An EEBO-TCP search finds both terms in earlier medical writing: Nicholas Gyer’s The English Phlebotomy (1592) discusses leanness and the body’s discharge of superfluities. They belong to a shared vocabulary of bodily health. Cuffe uses them in separate passages about nourishment and imbalance; Shakespeare brings them together to contrast the rich’s excess with the poor’s hunger.57
2 Henry VI: Arms wiping away dishonour
Savile’s translation of Tacitus gives a martial form of the blot-removal image (see “Blood washing away disgrace” above). In Histories 3.24, Antonius urges the Pannonian legions to recover their honour, asking:
for what purpose they had now resumed arms? if to wipe away the blot of their late ignominy, here was the field where they might reintegrate themselves in their honour again
Whitmore makes the same connection between a weapon, dishonour and a blot:
Never yet did base dishonor blur our name
But with our sword we wiped away the blot.— 2 Henry VI, 4.1, Whitmore.
Armed action wipes away a blot of dishonour and restores a damaged name. Savile’s translation and Whitmore’s speech share that complete proposition, making the comparison particularly pertinent beside Neville’s offer to remove his own disgrace through military service.58
Othello: Pliny and the Pontic Sea
Othello compares his resolve for revenge to a current that cannot turn back:
Like to the Pontic Sea,
Whose icy current and compulsive course
Ne’er feels retiring ebb, but keeps due on
To the Propontic and the Hellespont.
— Othello, 3.3
Pliny describes the same phenomenon. In Philemon Holland’s 1601 translation, the sea “evermore floweth and runneth out into Propontis,” but “never retireth back again within Pontus.” A surviving Aldine edition of Pliny’s Natural History, printed in Latin in 1535–36 and formerly at Billingbear, bears Henry Neville’s name. The passage therefore connects Othello’s striking image with a work represented among the surviving Neville books.59
Troilus and Cressida: Guazzo and Ulysses’ book
The Billingbear catalogue records Stefano Guazzo’s La civil conversatione, Venice, 1579. Guazzo explains that people learn their own faults and qualities through the responses of others. George Pettie’s English translation puts it sharply:
the judgment which we have to know ourselves, is not ours, but we borrow it of others.60
In Troilus and Cressida 3.3, Ulysses is reading when Achilles asks about his book. Their discussion turns on the same problem: a person cannot see his own qualities without their reflection in other people. Ulysses explains the author’s argument:
ULYSSES
I do not strain at the position—
It is familiar—but at the author’s drift,
Who in his circumstance expressly proves
That no man is the lord of anything—
Though in and of him there be much consisting—
Till he communicate his parts to others;
Nor doth he of himself know them for aught
Till he behold them formed in the applause
Where they’re extended; who, like an arch, reverb’rate
The voice again or, like a gate of steel
Fronting the sun, receives and renders back
His figure and his heat. […]61
In his 2018 article “The Conversational Turn in Shakespeare,” Shakespeare scholar John Gillies makes this comparison and asks whether Ulysses’ unnamed book might be Guazzo.62
The Winter’s Tale: Antigonus and Alexander’s successors
Shakespeare introduced Antigonus into The Winter’s Tale: neither the character nor his name was inherited from Greene’s Pandosto. Having chosen the name, Shakespeare places it only a few lines from Alexander and his successor in Paulina’s speech. Neville’s Advice likewise recalls Antigonus as “one of the immediate and mightiest successors of Alexander,” in a story about his trust in his son Demetrius:
PAULINA […]
As my Antigonus to break his grave
And come again to me–who, on my life,
Did perish with the infant. ‘Tis your counsel
[…]
The crown will find an heir. Great Alexander
Left his to th’ worthiest; so his successor
Was like to be the best.
— The Winter’s Tale, 5.1.
The pairing of Antigonus with Alexander’s succession is thus part of Shakespeare’s reshaping of the source story.63
Sonnet 99: Henry Constable
Henry Neville named the poet Henry Constable in his report to Cecil of 25 January 1600. Neville had obtained a cipher through a friar he was sending to Rome, and listed Constable among the English names for which it supplied special characters.64
Constable’s Diana (1592) contains a close parallel to Sonnet 99. Gerald Massey drew attention to the shared roses, lilies, purple violet and sweetness derived from the beloved. Both poems imagine flowers acquiring their beauty from a person, with several of the same details.65
The forward violet thus did I chide:
“Sweet thief, whence didst thou steal thy sweet that smells,
If not from my love’s breath? The purple pride
Which on thy soft cheek for complexion dwells
In my love’s veins thou hast too grossly dyed.”
The lily I condemnèd for thy hand,
And buds of marjoram had stol’n thy hair;
The roses fearfully on thorns did stand,
⌜One⌝ blushing shame, another white despair;
A third, nor red nor white, had stol’n of both,
And to his robb’ry had annexed thy breath;
But, for his theft, in pride of all his growth
A vengeful canker ate him up to death.
More flowers I noted, yet I none could see
But sweet or color it had stol’n from thee.— Shakespeare, Sonnet 99.66
Constable’s sonnet reads:
My lady’s presence makes the roses red,
Because to see her lips, they blush for shame:
The lilies’ leaves (for envy) pale became,
And her white hands in them this envy bred:
The marigold the leaves abroad doth spread,
Because the sun’s and her power is the same:
The violet of purple colour came,
Dyed in the blood she made my heart to shed.
In brief, all flowers from her their virtue take;
From her sweet breath, their sweet smells do proceed;
The living heat which her eye beams doth make,
Warmeth the ground, and quickeneth the seed:
The rain wherewith she watereth the flowers,
Falls from mine eyes, which she dissolves in showers.— Henry Constable, Diana (1592), Sonnet XVII.65
Sonnet 99 turns Constable’s floral tribute into an accusation of theft. Its violet steals sweetness and colour; its lily steals the whiteness of the beloved’s hand; one rose blushes with shame, another is white with despair. A third steals both colours and the beloved’s breath, and is punished by a canker. Constable supplies a close literary comparison, while Neville’s dispatch places the poet’s name in the diplomatic intelligence he was examining. That report does not establish a personal meeting or Neville’s possession of Diana.
Notes and sources
Shakespeare, All’s Well, 2.3, Folger text. The immediately preceding speech develops the image of scales and royal power to confer honour.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, Paris, 12 March 1600, Sawyer, Memorials, I, pp.158–160, quotation p.159. The heading, p.158, prints 12 March 1599 O.S.; the chapter modernizes the year without changing the Julian day. An EarlyPrint lemma search for counterpoise the balance, 7 September 2026, returned six indexed texts, including Gower’s Confessio Amantis (1483 and 1532) and Greene’s Vision (1592), TCP A02121. The other three results date from 1606, 1609 and 1684; the three earlier results represent two works, including two editions of Gower. This tests Neville’s phrase, not the frequency of the differently arranged pair in Shakespeare. No uniqueness or quantitative authorship claim is made.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, 15 May 1599 (Old Style), in Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer, I (London, 1725), p.24. Spelling and capitalization modernized from “dothe of yt.” The preceding sentence identifies “he” as the French ambassador. This is Neville’s English report of Henri IV’s speech; no original French wording has been established.↩︎
William Shakespeare, All’s Well That Ends Well, 2.1.175–176, Folger Shakespeare Library. Verse lineation retained; emphasis added.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, 15 May 1599, Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer, I (1725), p.22. Shakespeare, All’s Well That Ends Well, 2.1, Folger Shakespeare Library. The phrase has earlier witnesses: Robert Southwell, The triumphs over death (1595), describes a woman’s “wisedome, and constancie” as a “miracle in that sex” (TCP A12650); Rudolf Gwalther’s Homelyes … vppon the Actes (1572), Homily 28, p.204, joins amazement at the apostles with “wisedome and constancie” (TCP A14710). These are useful earlier contexts for Lafew’s praise.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, Boulogne, 25 June 1600, The National Archives, SP 78/44, f.194, transcription by John O’Donnell; spelling modernized. The opening links the journey to the Duke of Savoy’s refusal to surrender the marquisate or offer an exchange, and reports orders to raise troops. Later in the same letter Neville discusses d’Entragues and the Princess of Florence’s offer to join the king at Lyons. Compare Henri IV’s letters of 1 and 2 July 1600, Recueil des lettres missives, V, p.245, concerning his impending arrival at Lyons and the duke’s failure to fulfil his undertaking. In a search conducted on 29 September 2026, the three matching play records contain the actual word “thitherward,” not merely a lemma: All’s Well That Ends Well (assigned date 1603), Nabbes’s Hannibal and Scipio and Brome’s The Queen and Concubine (both assigned 1635). The dates are those assigned in the 527-play index. In the public EarlyPrint search, original-spelling CQL
[word=“(?i)thitherwards?”]returned 1,553 hits in 896 document records across the full collection; all hits were retrieved. Filtering the returned metadata to unambiguous four-digit publication years before 1600 gives 202 hits in 92 records. These are document/edition counts, not independent authors. Lemma and standardized-spelling searches also retrieve older forms such as “thyderwarde” and “thetherward”; the result is not created by lemmatization. For contemporary examples of the word in travel writing, see Hakluyt, The Principal Navigations (1599), TCP A02495. The dramatic distribution should not be mistaken for rarity throughout English print.↩︎William Shakespeare, All’s Well That Ends Well, 3.2, Folger Shakespeare Library. Verse lineation retained; emphasis added.↩︎
Neville to Winwood, Boulogne, 29 July 1600, in Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), p.232; Coriolanus 3.2. Spelling modernized. Neville was proposing reciprocal trade restrictions if the French refused relief. The pairing was already current in political writing: it appears in A True and Plaine Declaration of the Horrible Treasons, Practised by William Parry (1585; TCP A09049) and Holinshed’s Chronicles (1587; TCP A68202). A search of the EarlyPrint/EEBO index searched found nineteen document records containing “honour and policy,” four dated through 1603; among the 527 play records searched, only Coriolanus contained the phrase. Counts refer to contiguous lemmatized wording in the indexed texts.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, Earl of Salisbury, 14 January 1609 (1608/9), The National Archives, SP 14/43, f.30; John O’Donnell’s transcription, checked against the manuscript. Manuscript lineation is not reproduced. For the letter’s identification and financial request, see Mary Anne Everett Green, ed., Calendar of State Papers, Domestic Series, James I, 1603–1610 (1857), p.486, no.22 (British History Online). Shakespeare, Hamlet, 2.2.558–59, Folger Shakespeare Library; Folger line break retained. The letter postdates the early printed Hamlet texts. The reasoning has earlier parallels: Erasmus’s Paraphrase, second tome (1549), on 1 Timothy 1, has “The lesse that I deserue mercye, the more excellent is his clemencye” (TCP A68942); Robert Greene’s Arbasto (1589 witness) connects lesser desert with a greater obligation to repay kindness (TCP A02074). These supply a wider context of grace, favour and gratitude for the comparison.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, Earl of Salisbury, 14 January 1609, The National Archives, SP 14/43, f.30; John O’Donnell’s transcription collated with the manuscript. Spelling modernized and “Lo:p” expanded to “Lordship”; manuscript lineation is not reproduced. The biblical reference is John 5:2–9. Shakespeare, Venus and Adonis, 93–94, and Sonnet 153, 11–14, and Sonnet 154, 11–14, Folger Shakespeare Library. Venus’s water is figurative, following the description of her tears; she is asking for a kiss, not entering a healing pool. Paul Edmondson and Stanley Wells, introduction to All the Sonnets of Shakespeare (Cambridge University Press, 2020), pp.4–6, identify the sonnets’ classical source as an epigram by Marianus Scholasticus about Cupid’s torch heating a bath. These are comparisons of imagery, not established allusions to Bethesda. Venus and Adonis appeared in 1593; the sonnets’ publication in 1609 does not establish composition that year or a connection with Neville’s January letter.↩︎
Shakespeare, Henry IV, Part 1, 5.2, Folger Shakespeare. Worcester and Vernon return from the royal camp; Blunt’s earlier embassy is a separate exchange.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, Paris, 29 June 1599, Old Style, in Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer (London, 1725), I, pp. 53–55, quotation p. 54; page-image witness. Spelling and capitalization are modernized.↩︎
EarlyPrint public BlackLab search, 7 September 2026, consecutive lemmas “kind offer of the king”: four document hits, TCP A11966 (1598 quarto), A11954 (1623 Folio), A41748 (1683 letter of the Marquis of Grana) and A59501 (1700 Betterton adaptation). This is a result within that indexed collection, not a claim of universal uniqueness. The quarto’s imprint establishes publication before Neville’s letter: The History of Henrie the Fourth (London: P. Short for Andrew Wise, 1598), STC 22280, TCP A11966; EarlyPrint search interface.↩︎
Henry V, 1600 quarto, French king’s reply to the treaty articles, Internet Shakespeare Editions, ed. James D. Mardock, Q1, line 1588; spelling modernized. The fuller Folio text reads “Pass our accept and peremptory answer”: Folger, 5.2. Neville to Cecil, 20 March 1602, Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Marquess of Salisbury, XII, p. 80 (calendar abstract; manuscript reference 85.97); Neville to Winwood, 8 December 1604, Winwood, Memorials, II, pp. 37–38. Both printed letter witnesses inspected. In a search of 239 dramatic records assigned dates of 1590–1615, the exact singular phrase occurs only in Henry V; Jonson’s Every Man Out of His Humour (1599) has “peremptory answers,” about replies concerning a missing dog. Cornwallis also uses the expression in diplomatic correspondence. The EEBO search finds three indexed books dated by 1599 with the expression: Amorous Fiammetta (1587), Greene’s Ciceronis amor (1589), and Barrow’s A plaine refutation (1591). These bounded search results do not establish exclusivity to diplomacy or to Neville.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, 26 May 1599 (Old Style), in Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), p. 36. The continuation is headed “Of the same Date with the former.” Spelling and capitalization modernized; quotation checked against the printed page. Neville was discussing the repayment of money Elizabeth had lent the French king.↩︎
William Shakespeare, Henry VIII, 1.1, Folger Shakespeare Library, Buckingham on Charles V and Anglo-French relations. The extract preserves Folger’s line breaks; omissions are marked. The comparison concerns the diplomatic sense and political consequences of amity, not a claim that the word or sense was exclusive to Neville and Shakespeare. Holinshed already supplies the episode and its key term: the Emperor feared that a “faithfull bond of amitie” between the English and French kings “might turne him to displeasure.” See Chronicles (1587), vol. III, p. 856, TCP A68202. The play adapts that historical account; Neville’s letter supplies a later diplomatic parallel.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, Blois, 28 July 1599, in Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), p.76. Spelling, capitalization and light punctuation modernized; vocabulary and syntax retained. The “form of justice” is lawful procedure, not the merits of the initial English seizure.↩︎
Shakespeare, King Lear, 3.7, Folger. This is corresponding legal language, not a claim of a unique or exceptionally rare expression.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, between Amiens and Abbeville, 14 May 1600, in Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), pp.183–184. Spelling modernized. Neville was forwarding a letter brought by Villeroy’s messenger, addressed to the Queen, of which he had no copy. The contiguous lemmatized sequence “I thought it fit to send” returned only the First Folio in the EarlyPrint/EEBO index searched; among the 527 play records searched, it appeared only in King Lear. This is a count of the specified wording in the indexed texts, not of interrupted or paraphrased variants.↩︎
Neville to Winwood, 23 January 1600/1, Winwood, Memorials, vol. 1, p. 290; Shakespeare, Measure for Measure, 5.1. The January year is expressed here as 1601, with the printed old-style year identified in the citation. “Course of justice” already occurs in Richard III 4.4 and in Portia’s mercy speech in The Merchant of Venice, 4.1; this is continuity of register, not a first-use claim.↩︎
Shakespeare, Measure for Measure, 4.2, the Duke’s production of a letter announcing his return within two days. A handwritten, sealed order already appears in Cinthio’s Epitia (Venice, 1583), Act III, pp. 50–51; the comparison concerns Neville’s use of the formula.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, 19 November 1599 O.S., Winwood, Memorials, vol. 1, p. 130. The authorized representative was to demand and receive it and pursue his affairs in England.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, 9 May 1600, in Sawyer, ed., Memorials, I, p.182; Measure for Measure 3.1. Spelling modernized. Falstaff also asks, “Have you received no promise of satisfaction at her hands?” in The Merry Wives of Windsor 2.2. That play is usually dated before Neville’s letter. The EarlyPrint/EEBO search returned fifteen document records containing the phrase, none dated through 1603; these are indexed printed witnesses, not dates of composition or proof of first use.↩︎
Henry Neville, Advice touching the holding of a Parliament, in S. R. Gardiner, History of England, II (1863), Appendix V, p.393; printed page checked. Shakespeare, The Tempest, 1.2, Folger Shakespeare Library; lineation retained, emphasis added. Prospero disputes the timing of Ariel’s release: “Before the time be out?” The Advice belongs to the 1612–13 parliamentary discussions; its early copies are catalogued under July 1613. It therefore postdates the play’s first recorded performance, 1 November 1611, and is not established as its source. A public EarlyPrint search checked on 21 October 2026 for the consecutive lemmas which/be/not/yet/perform returned ten printed records, two dated through 1616: Roger Edgeworth’s Sermons (1557), A21119, and John Dove’s A Confutation of Atheisme (1605), A69226. Edgeworth also discusses a promise; Dove has “which are.” The later records include the First Folio and a 1670 adaptation of The Tempest. These are edition records, not independent usages. The broader search for promise followed by perform within twelve intervening words returned 5,657 EEBO records. Neville’s Advice is outside that printed collection.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, 26 September 1599, Winwood, Memorials, I (1725), p.114, printed witness. Spelling modernized; quotation begins within the sentence. Shakespeare, The Tempest, 5.1, Folger text; two separated portions of Prospero’s speech are shown with the intervening passage omitted. The correspondence is conceptual, not a shared verbal formula.↩︎
Neville to Winwood, London, 9 September 1600, in Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, I (1725), pp.253–254, quotations p.254; spelling modernized. Shakespeare, Troilus and Cressida, 2.2, Folger text. A search for the contiguous lemmatized sequence “touch my particular” in the EarlyPrint/EEBO index returned twelve document records. Its sole record dated before 1609 is a translated letter of the King of Navarre (1589; TCP A02971), which has the adjectival “touching my particular estate.” The noun construction also appears in Alexander Gardyne’s A Garden of Grave and Godly Flowers (1609; A01471), the same year as the Troilus quarto. In the drama database’s 239 play records assigned to 1590–1615, only Troilus contains the sequence, allowing inflected forms of “touch.” These are bounded corpus results, not proof of first use.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, 7 August 1599 Old Style, Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer, I (1725), p.85; Printed page inspected; spelling and capitalization modernized, and a divided word joined. Shakespeare, The Winter’s Tale, 1.2, Folger Shakespeare Library; verse lineation retained. “Save both” gathers up the inconvenience to Polixenes and the burden on his host. In the public EarlyPrint searches checked on 21 October 2026, the lemma sequence “charge and trouble” returned 477 EEBO document records, 33 dated through 1616. Requiring “save” to follow within eight intervening tokens returned four records (the First Folio of 1623, and records dated 1660, 1666 and 1681); allowing it on either side within twenty intervening tokens returned 34 records, including two dated through 1616. These are document/edition counts, not independent works. The wider search includes Francis Mason, Of the consecration of the bishops in the Church of England (1613), TCP A07192, reporting Henry VIII’s words about Cranmer’s proposal: “I might haue saued much charges and trouble.” John Bridges, The supremacie of Christian princes (1573), TCP A16835, likewise joins avoiding “charges and troubles of the lawe” with saving money. The narrow result depends on word order and should not be read as uniqueness. Neville’s correspondence is outside the searched printed collection.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, Earl of Salisbury, 14 January 1608/9, The National Archives, SP 14/43, ff. 29–30, opening on f. 29r. John O’Donnell’s transcription, checked against the manuscript image. Spelling, capitalization and punctuation modernized; emphasis added. ‘Imbecility’ here means weakness. The year is 1609 when numbered from 1 January.↩︎
Shakespeare, Sonnet 23, lines 5–12, Folger Shakespeare Library. Folger’s reading ‘books’ and its line breaks are retained; emphasis added. The comparison concerns the sequence of feeling, impeded speech and written expression, not an identical relationship between speaker and addressee.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, 31 July 1602, Hatfield House, Cecil Papers 94/90, holograph. Quotation follows John O’Donnell’s transcription, with spelling and punctuation modernized, checked against the manuscript. HMC, Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Marquess of Salisbury, XII (1910), p.268, abridges the passage and converts it to the third person. Shakespeare, 1 Henry IV, 3.2, Folger Shakespeare Library; verse lineation retained. The play was first printed in 1598, before Neville’s 1602 letter: see the Folger textual introduction. The comparison concerns imagery and purpose, not a claim that the later letter supplied the play.↩︎
Shakespeare, Lucrece, Folger Shakespeare Library, stanza beginning ‘Thou, Collatine, shalt oversee this will’. The poem was published in 1594, before Neville’s 1602 letter. This is a comparison of imagery; no rarity or direct borrowing is claimed.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, 6 May 1598, Hatfield House, Cecil Papers 60/114a. John O’Donnell’s transcription, checked against the manuscript image; ‘into’ follows the manuscript. Spelling, capitalization and punctuation modernized; emphasis added. The date reads ‘vith’, not 19 May. The recognizances were binding legal obligations; the reciprocal assurances concerned the completion of the land transaction.↩︎
Shakespeare, The Merchant of Venice, 1.1, and Hamlet, 5.1, Folger Shakespeare Library. Line breaks retained; omissions marked and emphasis added. Recognizances and assurances are established legal terms; no claim of lexical exclusivity is made.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, 14 May 1600, Winwood, Memorials, I, p.184. Shakespeare, 3 Henry VI, 4.1; compare Measure for Measure, 2.3: “And try your penitence, if it be sound / Or hollowly put on.” The latter is a related metaphorical opposition, not the same reference to friendship.↩︎
Independent exact-adjacency comparison, 28 July 2026, rechecked 29 September 2026, using the plays described in Pervez Rizvi’s corpus documentation. The check joined consecutive word tokens within each play, ignoring capitalization, and counted matching play documents in the 239-play selection dated 1590–1615. It returned the four Shakespeare titles named here and Jonson’s Sejanus. The initial report used a 1590–1616 window; the present count is explicitly for 1590–1615. This was an exploratory discovery from inspected phrase results. Wider print use was checked in EarlyPrint; the phrase is not unique to drama or to these writers. The dates in the comparison database are working composition dates, not dates of surviving drafts.↩︎
Neville to Robert Cecil, Paris, 12 March 1599/1600 O.S., Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer, I (London, 1725), p. 158. The printed heading gives 1599 O.S.; the year is 1600 when numbered from 1 January. Spelling and capitalization modernized. “I suppose” preserves Neville’s qualification about Sillery’s whereabouts. The quotation is from the printed edition.↩︎
Folger Shakespeare Library, Measure for Measure, 1.3, King Lear, 5.3, Timon of Athens, 5.1, and Coriolanus, 3.1. Line breaks retained. Timon is a collaborative work; the count is of plays in the Shakespeare canon, not four independently established Shakespeare-only passages. See Folger’s discussion of its authorship. The Coriolanus passage follows North’s Plutarch (1579), Life of Caius Martius Coriolanus, p. 245: Greek cities had “more absolute power,” and free corn would “nourishe their disobedience” to the “ruine and ouerthrowe of the whole state.” See the 1579 text, TCP A09802. This identifies the source of that occurrence; it does not establish the source of the earlier use in Measure for Measure.↩︎
Henry Neville to Ralph Winwood, 21 June 1605, Edmund Sawyer, ed., Memorials of Affairs of State, II (1725), pp. 77–78, quotation p. 78, checked against the printed page. Neville to Winwood, Eton, 13 August 1609, Buccleuch and Queensberry MSS., Winwood Papers; quotation follows John O’Donnell’s transcription, not a fresh manuscript collation. The letter is calendared in the Historical Manuscripts Commission’s Report on the Manuscripts of the Duke of Buccleuch and Queensberry, I (1899), p. 82. Shakespeare, Cymbeline, 3.2, Folger Shakespeare Library. Neville’s spelling and capitalization modernized; emphasis added. The formula also appears in Barnabe Rich’s dedicatory closing to The Adventures of Brusanus (1592), TCP A10697, and in Thomas Kyd’s dedication to his translation of Robert Garnier’s Cornelia (1594), TCP A01500. Gervase Markham’s Hobsons Horse-load of Letters (1613), TCP A06933, has “wishing you all happiness and contentment.” A search including spelling and grammatical variants found the formula only in Cymbeline among 239 dramatic texts dated 1590–1615, but in eleven printed document records dated by 1615 in EEBO/EarlyPrint, including repeated editions. Kyd’s example is in the dedication, not the dramatic dialogue. These examples establish its wider use as a letter-closing formula.↩︎
Speeches delivered to Her Maiestie this last progresse (Oxford: Joseph Barnes, 1592), STC 7600, TCP A21246, Rycote section, sig. C3r, printed page. Spelling and punctuation modernized; emphasis added. The entertainment is anonymous. The comparison concerns its soldier-wooer rhetoric, not an attribution of the entertainment to Neville.↩︎
Shakespeare, Henry V, 5.2. Folger line breaks retained; emphasis added. The excerpt continues through Henry’s offer of physical feats; the ellipsis marks the continuation of his speech.↩︎
Myers & Co., An Illustrated Catalogue of Rare Books, Historical Documents, Autograph Letters, Etc., no. 214 (1917), p. 31, item 140. The catalogue dates the letter 8 October 1599; if this is a misreading of 1592, the recipient was Neville’s father. The manuscript has not been located.↩︎
Speeches delivered to Her Maiestie (1592), Rycote section, speech accompanying delivery of the key, TCP A21246. Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, 7 January 1602/3, Hatfield House, Cecil Papers 91/35, holograph; spelling and punctuation modernized. The manuscript reads ‘alwaies avow’ in the parenthesis. HMC, Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Marquess of Salisbury, XII (1910), pp.589–590, printed calendar, identifies and abridges the letter but omits the blood-seal clause; that clause is quoted from the manuscript.↩︎
A true report of Sir Anthony Shierlies iourney ouerland to Venice (London, 1600), TCP B15781, oration to the Persian ruler, text; printed witness. Spelling modernized. The report supplies a comparator, not evidence of Neville’s involvement in its composition or translation.↩︎
Speeches delivered to Her Maiestie this last progresse (Oxford: Joseph Barnes, 1592), STC 7600, TCP A21246, final Rycote messenger, text. Spelling and punctuation modernized; omissions marked. Shakespeare, As You Like It, 3.2, Folger Shakespeare Library, Orlando’s poem as read by Celia. The entertainment is anonymous.↩︎
Eunapius, The lives of philosophers and oratours (London, 1579), TCP A00437, life of Proaeresius: ‘clapping his owne hands, at euery sentence ende’; text. Spelling modernized in the discussion. This earlier occurrence precludes treating the phrase as exclusive to Rycote and Shakespeare.↩︎
Neville to Cecil, 13 July 1599, Winwood, vol. I, p. 66. The letter reports the ceremony and observations about the crowd; the quoted passage does not explicitly establish that Neville personally witnessed it.↩︎
Macbeth 4.3. Malcolm’s description is followed by Ross’s arrival and report from Scotland.↩︎
Holinshed, Chronicles (1577), English history, p. 279, Edward the Confessor: EarlyPrint/TCP A03448. The account attributes to Edward both healing and prophecy, and transmission of the healing virtue to succeeding kings. For the practice and the identification of the disease, Royal College of Physicians, “The king’s evil”. Neville’s letter supplies contemporary diplomatic experience of the ceremony; Holinshed supplies the historical episode and hereditary claim.↩︎
Henry Neville, declaration of 2 March 1601, The National Archives, SP 12/279, document beginning at fol. 15. John O’Donnell’s transcription, with spelling and punctuation modernized; emphasis added. The declaration is reproduced in Appendix M. The comparison concerns kinship, obligation and reputation, not a distinctive verbal formula or an identical sequence of arguments.↩︎
William Shakespeare, Macbeth, 1.7, Folger Shakespeare Library, lines 12–16 and 34–38. Emphasis added; omissions marked; verse lineation retained.↩︎
A Rehearsall Both Straung and True (1579), TCP A12973, Stile’s reported confession. John Roche Dasent, ed., Acts of the Privy Council of England, new series XI, 1578–1580 (1895), pp.20–22, entry for 16 January 1578/9, instruction on p.22. The year is modernized to 1579. The named magistrate was the elder Sir Henry Neville, not his son.↩︎
Shakespeare, The Two Gentlemen of Verona, 2.4, and King John, 5.4, Folger Shakespeare Library. Verse lineation retained; omissions marked and emphasis added. The shared motif does not establish borrowing from the Windsor pamphlet.↩︎
Shakespeare, A Midsummer Night’s Dream, 1.1, Folger Shakespeare Library. The conjuration involving the Duchess of Gloucester in Henry VI, Part 2, 1.4 offers a separate example of politically dangerous magic, but the scene specifies no wax figure.↩︎
Shakespeare, All’s Well That Ends Well, 1.1; John Davies of Hereford, Microcosmos (Oxford, 1603), “To the Noble, discreete, and wellbeloved Knight Sir Henry Nevill,” printed poem. Ken Feinstein proposed the comparison in “Possible parallel between All’s Well and Microcosmos”, 13 September 2021. This is a rhetorical correspondence; no rarity or direction of borrowing is claimed.↩︎
Henry Cuffe, The Differences of the Ages of Mans Life (London, 1607), discussions of mixture, digestion and nutrition, and of immoderate watching; TCP A19683. Spelling modernized. The title page dates the work’s writing to 1600. The two quotations come from separate passages. For Cuffe’s approaches to Neville, see Neville’s declaration, 2 March 1601, The National Archives, SP 12/279, f. 15, and the document’s discussion in the Macbeth chapter; also Calendar of State Papers, Domestic, Elizabeth, 1601–1603, ed. M. A. E. Green (1870), pp. 5–8, item 11.↩︎
Shakespeare, Coriolanus, 1.1. No numerical rarity claim is made for the paired vocabulary.↩︎
EEBO-TCP lemma searches for leanness and superfluity (including plural forms), 29 September 2026: 191 indexed texts contain both; eight place them within a 100-token NEAR window, across the indexed material through 1649. These are text/edition counts, not independent authors. Nicholas Gyer, The English Phlebotomy (1592), chapter 9, TCP A02428, discusses the constitution of bodies suitable for bleeding. Cuffe’s nearest occurrences are 304 lemma-token positions apart (TCP A19683), so they do not constitute an adjacent phrase. The comparison concerns the use of shared medical vocabulary, not verbal exclusivity.↩︎
Tacitus, The Ende of Nero and Beginning of Galba. Fower Bookes of the Histories, trans. Henry Savile (Oxford, 1591), Histories 3.24, TCP A13331. Shakespeare, 2 Henry VI, 4.1, Folger Shakespeare Library. The Whitmore lines belong to the fuller text preserved in the First Folio (1623); the 1594 quarto omits this speech. The date of the surviving witness is not a date of composition.↩︎
Pliny, Natural History, II.219; Philemon Holland, trans., The Historie of the World (1601), II, chapter 97 (English text; Latin text). Holland’s spelling is modernized here. Shakespeare, Othello, 3.3. For the surviving Aldine set, see Sotheby’s, Bibliotheca Brookeriana: The Aldine Collection N–Z, 25 June 2025, lot 1325, and the library discussion in this book. No annotation at this passage has been established; the comparison does not determine whether Shakespeare used Pliny’s Latin or Holland’s translation.↩︎
Royal Berkshire Archives, D/EN/F37/1, Catalogue of the Books in the Library at Billingbear, 7 November 1780, entry “La civil Conversatione del Signor Guazzo,” Venice, 1579; catalogue record. Stefano Guazzo, The Civile Conversation, translated by George Pettie, first three books (London: Richard Watkins, 1581), book II, p.4, TCP A02291, text. Spelling modernized. The English wording illustrates the Italian work’s argument; it is not evidence that this English edition was Neville’s copy.↩︎
William Shakespeare, Troilus and Cressida, 3.3, Folger Shakespeare Library. The extract ends partway through the line continuing “I was much rapt in this”; the following words are omitted. The exchange begins with Achilles asking what Ulysses is reading.↩︎
John Gillies, “The Conversational Turn in Shakespeare,” Études Épistémè 33 (2018), §§32–34. Gillies proposes the identification as a question, “Guazzo?”, rather than identifying the stage property with certainty.↩︎
An Advice [by Sir Henry Neville] Touching the Holding of a Parliament, in S. R. Gardiner, History of England, II (1863), Appendix V, p.390. The story of Antigonus receiving his armed son Demetrius before ambassadors appears in Plutarch’s Life of Demetrius, section 3, including Thomas North’s translation (1579), p.942. Its presence does not identify North as the exclusive source of the Advice’s wording. The Advice belongs to the parliamentary discussions of 1612–13; no direction of borrowing is established here. In Shakespeare, The Winter’s Tale, 5.1, Paulina invokes her dead husband before turning to the royal succession: “The crown will find an heir. Great Alexander / Left his to th’ worthiest; so his successor / Was like to be the best.” Slashes mark verse line breaks. Paulina’s husband is not the historical Antigonus of Plutarch, and her Alexander anecdote is different from the Advice’s story. For Antigonus as a character introduced by Shakespeare, see Esther French, “How we got The Winter’s Tale and where it went from there,” Folger Shakespeare Library, 6 October 2023, quoting the Folger edition’s editors on Shakespeare’s additions to Greene. This establishes the departure from Pandosto, not why Shakespeare selected the name.↩︎
Henry Neville to Robert Cecil, Paris, 25 January 1599/1600 Old Style, in Ralph Winwood, Memorials of Affairs of State, ed. Edmund Sawyer, I (London, 1725), pp.146–147, especially p.147. The year is 1600 in modern year numbering. This is the acquired cipher described in Neville’s report, not an identification of Henry Constable in the surviving embassy key, SP 106/2. Inclusion in the vocabulary permits a correspondent to refer to him in code; it does not establish his participation in the correspondence.↩︎
Henry Constable, Diana. The praises of his mistres, in certaine sweete sonnets. By H.C. (London: John Charlewood for Richard Smith, 1592), Sonnet XVII, headed “Sonnetto decisette,” EEBO-TCP A19223. Spelling, capitalization and punctuation modernized; lineation retained, printer’s pointing hand omitted, emphasis added. Gerald Massey, The Secret Drama of Shakspeare’s Sonnets (1888), part I, discussion comparing Sonnet 99 with Constable. The textual parallels are the point cited here; the date of Diana follows the 1592 edition, not Massey’s erroneous 1584.↩︎
William Shakespeare, Sonnet 99, Folger Shakespeare Library. Wording, punctuation and verse lineation retained; emphasis added.↩︎