Home / Topics / Arthur Warren's Poore Mans Passions as a Timon Analogue

Arthur Warren's Poore Mans Passions as a Timon Analogue

Mixed Needs Review evidence packet

Topic: Arthur Warren's Poore Mans Passions as a Timon Analogue

Why This Text Entered the Project

This book was not found by searching for a title already associated with Shakespeare. It emerged from a positional search of the pre-1611 EarlyPrint corpus for passages bringing together at least five of seven ideas in Henry Neville's 10 January 1600 letter to Thomas Windebank: gate, table, purse, burden, credit, honour, and forest/wood. Arthur Warren's The Poore Mans Passions. And Pouerties Patience (1605, EEBO-TCP A14793, STC 25093) had the second-tightest result in the corpus: burden, gate, honour, purse, and table occurred within 257 token positions.

Reading the passage showed that the computational hit is substantially more interesting than a bag of common words. Warren joins simple hermit food, honour and gain, costly hospitality, great halls and tables, an emptied purse, a cottage or cell, and burdens that can be borne. These are also central elements in Neville's embassy complaint and in Shakespeare's dramatization of Timon's hospitality, financial collapse, rejection of honour, and retreat.

Source-Control Position

Quoted Source Passages: Direct EarlyPrint Passage

The local token stream reads:

"Rootes, Onions, garlick, and the Hermits meale, / Proves better feasting then this dangerous fare"

"abstinence and temperance attaine / The marke of honour and the meanes of gaine"

"A little cottage common cloth short meales / Is safest seate best rayment surest health"

"It's sumptuous lodge rich vesture daintie fare / That robbe the purse and make reuenewes bare"

"great halls large tables gold plate little meate / Feed but the eye while mouth hath nought to eate"

"elect riches of a diuiner sort / Choose burthens which thou better maist support / Content in celles seemes richer by degrees / Then discontent inthron'd in courts of kings"

The spelling and punctuation above have been lightly supplied from the continuous EarlyPrint word stream for readability. A final book quotation should be collated against the Folger page image.

Relation to Neville's Windebank Letter

Neville writes that the French embassy is a burden that is especially heavy for his purse; because English gentlemen continually arrive, he cannot shut my gates, nor refuse my table; he continues for the Queen's honnour and his own credit, then exclaims fie vpon honnour that brings no profit and imagines becoming an hermit in Ashridge or somwhere in the forrest.

Warren's poem does not repeat Neville's phrases. It does, however, place an unusually similar set of contrasts in a compact moral argument:

Neville, 1600Warren, 1605
burden too heavyChoose burthens which thou better maist support
especially for my pursecostly fare and buildings robbe the purse
cannot shut gates/refuse tablegreat halls large tables and expensive hospitality
honour brings no profithonour paired with gaine
become a hermitthe Hermits meale; content in celles
Ashridge or forest retreatA little cottage as the safer seat

This could represent a shared contemporary language of debt, hospitality, and withdrawal. It could also identify a printed analogue available close to the likely composition period of Timon. Both possibilities deserve investigation.

Relation to Timon of Athens

The poem's themes overlap the play's movement from sumptuous hospitality to poverty and withdrawal: tables and feasting; a purse exhausted by generosity; honour altered by want; humble food set against dangerous luxury; and content outside the court. The sequence is not the plot of Timon, and no distinctive verbal borrowing has yet appeared.

A normalized n-gram comparison between the entire EarlyPrint A14793 word stream and the Folger Timon text found only one shared five-word sequence, is t possible the world, which is not distinctive. This is important documentation: Warren is presently a close thematic and conceptual analogue, not an identified verbal source.

Corpus Context

The positional script searched every EarlyPrint document dated through 1610 with positional lemma data. It found 2,451 documents containing at least five of the seven concepts somewhere in the document. Their tightest five-concept windows were:

Warren ranked second at 257. The only tighter document was the very long 1608 English History of Our B. Lady of Loreto at 235, using a different five-term combination. Neville's relevant letter passage runs from purse to forest across approximately 114 normalized word positions, with gate, table, honour, and credit between them. This establishes that Neville's cluster is unusually compact in this corpus search. It does not establish dependence or authorship.

The comparison also clarified that broad document-level co-occurrence is not useful: more than a thousand pre-1611 documents contain gate, table, and purse somewhere in the same book. Position and passage meaning are essential.

New Research Routes

  1. Obtain or access the Folger page images and cite the exact signature and page containing the quoted stanzas.
  2. Search the full Warren poem for Timon-relevant classical names, images of false friends, gifts, gold, flatterers, roots, beasts, Athens, and exile.
  3. Examine James Roberts and Richard Bankworth's publishing networks. Roberts printed Shakespeare quartos, so the fact that he printed Warren is potentially useful publication context, though not evidence of source use by itself.
  4. Identify Robert Quarme, Warren's dedicatee, and test his social and geographical connections.
  5. Revisit the old proposal that Warren was the A. W. of Poetical Rhapsody and manuscript Harl. MS 6910/Harl. MS 280. If that identification can be strengthened, Warren's verse had a manuscript life before 1605 and a Sidney-connected literary setting.
  6. Compare the poem scene-by-scene not only with Timon but with King Lear, whose poverty, exposure, hospitality, and unaccommodated man concerns belong to the same 1604-1606 period.

New Biographical Identification Lead: Warren, Quarme, and Abigail

The dedication may preserve a family relationship that standard accounts of the poet have missed.

Warren addresses Robert Quarme as his kindest Fauourer, Patron, and friend, gives him his Passions and Patience, promises that his hand will attend him if serviceable, and says he has no Currant with which to repay him except love, affection, and gratitude. A nineteenth-century Cornish bibliography identifies the dedicatee as Robert Quarme, of Nancar in Creed.

The 1887 edition of the Cornwall visitations supplies a primary-derived family fact. On page 388, in the Quarme of Mawnan pedigree, Robert Quarme of Woodhouse/St Keverne and Bridget Webber have a daughter:

Abigall, mar. 22 Aug. 1614 at Constantine to William Hext.

The page states that the italic portion comes from the original 1620 visitation, Harl. MS. 1162, signed by Robert Quarme; the marriage date itself is footnoted to the Constantine parish register. The Hext pedigree on page 222 independently names her Abigail, Da. of Robert Quarme and gives the same date.

The Constantine marriage index adds the crucial missing detail: William Hext married Abigail WARREN, whose condition is W. (widow), on 22 August 1614. Its stated transcription source is Phillimore. The conjunction means that Robert Quarme's daughter Abigail was the widow of a Warren when she remarried.

This does not yet prove that her first husband was the poet Arthur Warren. No first-marriage record or burial/probate record for Arthur has been located in this pass, and an indexed Cornwall burial search for Arthur Warren in 1604-1614 returned no result. Nevertheless, the hypothesis is specific and economical: Arthur Warren may have dedicated the book to his father-in-law, Robert Quarme, and died before Abigail's remarriage in 1614. It would explain both the unusually personal dedication and the otherwise obscure connection between Warren and a Cornish gentleman.

The next records to seek are:

  1. Abigail Quarme's first marriage, possibly outside a currently indexed Cornish parish;
  2. an Arthur Warren burial, administration, debtor-prison, Chancery, or probate record between 1605 and 1614, possibly in London;
  3. Robert Quarme's 1628 will, Kresen Kernow AP/Q/16, which may name Abigail, grandchildren, or a deceased son-in-law;
  4. William Hext's 1633 probate and settlement papers, which may describe Abigail's prior marriage or Warren property;
  5. the original Constantine register entry and the original visitation manuscript, to control every editorial layer.

Citations and Research Record

Current Conclusion

Arthur Warren's 1605 poem is a newly documented Timon analogue and a promising source-history lead. Its importance is the compact conjunction of hospitality, purse, honour/gain, hermit or cell, humble food, and manageable burdens. The present tests found no distinctive shared phrase with Timon, so future work should focus on page-image collation, chronology, publication and manuscript circulation, and the structure of the poverty/hospitality argument.

Notes on Access